Now that it is summer and teaching art classes are finished until fall, I like to think about the classes I have taught and any unique experiences from the classes. In one particular class I had an interesting experience with one of my students.
During the first class, I take role call and ask that each student tell me why they are taking the class or what attracted them to class. There are some standard answers: to learn a new medium; to get better at this particular medium; try something new, and meet new people or to take a class with my friend or friends. On this particular day, one of the students said that she was “stuck in her style.” She said that she wanted to change but didn’t know how and thought that my class could help her. I had made notes while the students were talking and adjusted my teaching plan based on their answers to my question.
There were several activities that first class to get the students loosened up and thinking. We talked about the project or homework that would be due for the next week. I also assigned them some creativity activates to try during the next week and asked them to bring the results of the activities to the class.
I had high hopes that these creative activities in particular would help the student who was “stuck in her style.” They had been highly successful for students in previous classes.
The day of the second class arrived. Everyone was there and we looked at the completed projects of the students. While talking about their work, many students commented that the creativity activities directly influenced and enhanced their finished project. The time came for the student who had said that she was “stuck” to talk about her artwork. She stated that the finished project was her typical style. That she had not done the creative activities because she “just wasn’t feeling them.”
After our gentle critique of each others work, I had selected several projects that everyone participated in. Even my stuck student. Most students were talking and sharing, showing each other things that they had learned in their experimentations. Stuck student stuck to herself. While the others left with their experiments and ideas shared with the group, she threw her experiments away.
I thought to myself, that there had to be a way to help this person. So I completely changed the third class to be an entirely hands on experience that would build up to their homework or final project for the class. I was really excited for the class. The students arrived and we had a gentle critique of the artworks produced. Stuck student hadn’t done the project at all. She did not give an explanation as to why.
After the critique, I did several demonstrations and set up tables for the students to try their hand at the techniques I had shown them. Everyone was having fun. Spending time at the different tables. With the exception of one student. I could give you three guesses but you will only need one….
One of the techniques, I had taught the students required the use of a pipette. Also I had prepared handouts on the techniques for the class. After all of the students had left for the day, I was cleaning up the classroom. Stuck student had left her hand-outs and the pipette. I was feeling very discouraged.
The day before the final class, I was really struggling. I did not want to deal with that student, when everyone else was so excited and interested. Thankfully, stuck student texted me that she was ill and would not be attending class. My dark cloud lifted and I was excited to go again.
That particular class had been a real challenge for me. I didn’t realize how hard I had been trying to help and how much it bothered me until talking with another artist friend of mine, who also teaches. She shared a similar experience she had, had with a student. At the end of her story, she said, “Some people don’t really want to be helped or learn.”
My friend was completely right. Have you heard the proverb, “You can lead a horse to water but you cannot make him drink.” It is one of the oldest English proverbs still in use today. And it means that people like horses can be shown or given something, but that does not mean that they will take advantage of the opportunity.
Stuck student was my horse that I had lead to water. She really didn’t want to change. I’m not really sure why she took the class. Maybe she needed myself and the other students to tell her that her artwork was good? I will probably never know. I do hope she finds what she is looking for.